Preview Mode Links will not work in preview mode

Hosts Kelly Burdick and Christina Knott return to the pages of history for stories that still matter today.

Apr 26, 2020

Capt. William O’Toole, 45, Clayton, a native of Constableville and son of Civil War soldier and Irish immigrant, Peter O’Toole, piloted the Hartford. In addition to the captain, also lost when the ship went down were his wife, Mary Manson O’Toole and their 5-month-old child, Mary Kathleen, along with four others.

The O’Tooles left five other children orphans, who after the tragedy were cared for by their 68-year-old grandmother, Sarah O’Toole of Clayton.

Accompanying the washing up of the skeletal remains of the ship last month came fresh reflections about the captain of the doomed vessel by his descendants.

Chris Brock joines Kelly Burdick, Christina Knott and Dennis O'Brien to discuss. Visit the Watertown Daily Times at to read the full story on the schooner section’s resurrection. Read the poem here.

This episode is edited by Christina Knott. Intro music is "Nobody Calls It San Fran" by Coyote Hearing. Outro music is "The Papergirl" by The Whole Other. Browse our new merch at Society 6.

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram; email us at To subscribe to the Watertown Daily Times at NNY360, visit

You can also follow our affiliate link to get a free audio book from and try it out for 30 days. Enter our promo code "secondlook" at or visit